E. Ferentinou, Artificial Intelligence in Civil Proceedings, 2026
The present treatise addresses the timely and complex issue of the integration of AI systems into civil courts, identifying their current applications and assessing their implications for the fundamental procedural guarantees of a fair trial.
The monograph initially examines the historical development of the use of AI tools in legal practice, from the late 20th century up to the past decade, before turning to the EU regulatory framework set out in Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (the AI Act) and the implications of classifying AI tools used in the administration of justice as of “high-risk”. The analysis then focuses on existing AI applications that have been integrated into the administration of justice in civil courts worldwide, with emphasis on the European context, systematically categorised into a three-tier classification: from administrative and organisational support tools (Level 1), to systems to assist in judicial decision-making, legal research, the taking of evidence and the prediction of judicial decisions (Level 2), to models of fully-automated judicial decision-making (Level 3), whose constitutionality is being contested.
In addition to the above issues, the study focuses specifically on examining the impact of algorithmic technology on the rule-of-law guarantees under Article 6 of the ECHR and the fundamental procedural principles of the Greek Code of Civil Procedure. In this perspective, the “black box” problem is thoroughly examined in relation to the obligation to provide reasons in court decisions, as well as the risks of algorithmic bias and automation bias, investigated in regard to the principle of judicial impartiality. Furthermore, the challenges concerning the equality of arms, the adversarial proceedings and the principle of court proceedings publicity are being studied.
Finally, the project concludes with an examination of the Greek legislative framework for the introduction of AI tools into the domestic legal system, analysing existing and pilot applications in civil courts, as well as the National Cadastre.
Edition info
Table of contents +-
Table of Contents
Preface
Acknowledgements
Table of Abbreviations
Chapter
Introduction
I. The Genesis of a Field
II. The Focus: Artificial Intelligence in Civil Procedural Law
III. The Study’s Trajectory
Chapter
Artificial Intelligence in Law: A Brief History
I. The Enduring Quest to Model Legal Reasoning
II. The Early Years (1970s-1980s)
1. The Rise of Expert Systems (1980s) and the Relevant Core Challenges.
i. The Primacy of Knowledge Representation
ii. The Inherent Ambiguity of Law: The Problem of ‘Open Texture’
iii. The Challenge of Legal Inference
2. The First Generation of Legal AI
III. How to Model Civil Proceedings? (1990s-early 2000s)
1. Modeling Argumentation and Procedure
2. The Intertwining of Rules and Cases and the Representation of Precedents as Formal Rules
IV. Reasoning, Arguments and Summaries (2000s)
1. Advancements in Case-Based Reasoning
2. The Formalisation of Argumentation Schemes
3. Summarisation and Argumentation Mining
V. The Data-Driven Transformation (2010s-early 2020s)
1. Semantic Web Applications in Legal Information Management
2. The Ascendancy of Machine Learning
VI. Interim Conclusion
Chapter
(Legal) AI: The complexities of Its Definition
Ι. Τhe Arduous Τask of Defining Artificial Ιntelligence
1. The OECD’s and the European Union’s AI Act Definitions
2. Better describing AI’s Capabilities Rather Than Defining It?
Chapter
The EU’s AI Act Regulatory Framework on Legal AI
I. Classification of Legal AI as High-Risk, Its Rationale and Exceptions
1. The Rule
2. The Exceptions
II. The Relevant Mandatory Requirements for High-Risk Legal AI
Chapter
Applications of AI in Civil Proceedings
I. Artificial Intelligence as a Progressive Step Forward in the Digitalisation of Civil Litigation
II. The 3-Tier Categorisation of Artificial Intelligence Applications in Civil Justice
1. Organisational Tool in the Administration of Justice (Level 1)
i. Case Entry, Classification, and Preliminary Management
ii. Case Allocation
iii. Transcription of Hearings
iv. Name Recognition Within Judicial Documents
v. Anonymisation of Judicial Decisions
2. Decision-Making Support (Level 2)
i. Legal Research, Information Retrieval and Named Entity Recognition (NER)
ii. Summarisation
iii. Preparation and Drafting of Legal Documents
iv. Evidence and Discovery
v. Legal Judgment Prediction
3. Automation of Judicial Decision-Making (Level 3)
i. Legal Considerations Upon AI as a Decision-Making Body
ii. (The Lack of) Legality of Fully Automated Adjudication, in Light of the Principle of the Protection of Human Dignity
iii. Related ΑΙ Applications
a. Arbitration, Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) and Justice-Apps
b. (Semi-)Automated Payment Orders
Chapter
AI and fair trial rights
I. Introductory remarks
II. The ‘Black-Box’ Problem
1. AI opacity Towards the Right to a Reasoned Judgment
2. The Jurisprudential Response
i. National Courts
ii. CJEU
3. Steps Towards AI’s Explainability
III. Judicial Impartiality, Algorithmic Discrimination & Automation Bias.
1. Τhe Right to an Ιmpartial Τribunal Through the Lens of AI-assisted Adjudication
2. Automation Bias
IV. Adversarial Proceedings and Equality of Arms
1. General Overview
2. Impact on Adversarial Proceedings
3. Effect on the Principle of Equality of Arms
V. The Right to a Public Hearing
1. The Μain Οutline of this Right
2. Implications for the Right to a Public Hearing Through the Automation of Adjudication
VI. Judicial Discretion as an Aspect of the Human Administration of Justice.
VΙI. Future Prospects, Opportunities, and Risks of AI in Civil Justice
1. Predictions for the Future Development of AI in Civil Justice
2. Opportunities and Risks Foreseen
Chapter
Artificial Intelligence in the Greek Civil Justice System
I. A Comprehensive Overview of the Greek Legal Framework on AI (General and Sector-Specified)
1. The Greek Approach on Defining Artificial Intelligence
2. Strategic Documents on AI and Digitalisation of the Greek Civil Justice System
3. National Legislation Governing Artificial Intelligence
i. The General Regulatory Framework: Law 4961/2022
ii. Recent Greek Legislation on Artificial Intelligence in Sector-defined Fields and the Implementation of the AI Act in Those Areas
a. Public Administration and Digital Governance
b. Healthcare
c. Education
iii. With Particular Regard to the Administration of Justice: Laws 4820/2021 and 4871/2021
iv. Impact of the AI Act on the Greek Legal Order
v. Planned Legislative Initiatives Related to AI Regulation in Civil Justice
4. Assessment of the Regulatory Framework for Artificial Intelligence in Civil Justice
i. The Effectiveness of the Current Legal and Regulatory Framework
ii. Gaps of Underregulation and Persisting Areas of Concern
II. Data Protection, Security and Liability for AI Systems in Civil Justice.
1. Data Protection
i. Measures Ensuring Compliance with Data Protection Regulations
ii. Oversight by National Data Protection Authorities
iii. Τhe Relevant Case Law
2. Security of AI Systems
i. EU’s Safeguards Ensuring the Security and Integrity of AI Systems in Civil Justice
ii. National Regulations and Standards for Securing AI Tools
3. Liability for AI-Related Errors
i. General Regulation of Liability for Errors Made by AI Systems in the Judiciary
ii. Special Liability Frameworks for AI-related Mistakes in Civil Proceedings
III. Contemporary, Pilot and Proposed AI Applications within the Greek Legal System
1. AI Applications in Civil Justice
i. Contemporary AI Applications
ii. Pilot AI Applications
iii. Planned or Proposed AI Applications
2. AI in Land Registers
3. AI-Supported E-Services
4. Costs and Efficiency
IV. AI in the Judiciary
1. Soft-Law Instruments
2. International Cooperation
3. Training of Judges and Court Employees
V. Public Perception and Trust of AI Integration in the Greek Justice System
Chapter
Conclusions
Table of Bibliography
Index
Table of Statutes

















